◆ ECONSTELLAR Classroom Market Forces Lab Macro Vitals Lab Market Maker · L1 Signal Room · L2 Peer Review econstellars.com
Communication skills · paperless assessment

Peer Review

Score a classmate's presentation from your phone. Six metrics, each scored from 1 to 6 against written descriptors, and one comment. No paper, nothing to print.

The presentation

Your roll number is remembered on this device

Six metrics

1 to 6 · no middle score · pick the band, then the lower or higher score in it

Score the presentation, not the person. There is no neutral middle: decide whether each aspect sat on the weaker side (1 to 3) or the stronger side (4 to 6). Keep 6 for work you would show next year's class as a model.

Comment

Optional · shared with the presenter without your name

– / 36
0 of 6 metrics scored

The six metrics follow the criteria business schools commonly use to assess presentations, built on the AAC&U Oral Communication VALUE rubric: a clear message, depth and accuracy of content, organisation, supporting evidence and visuals, delivery, and engagement with the audience. The descriptors carry the conventions of management communication teaching: state the point first, one idea per slide, and answer the question that was asked. The 6-point scale has no midpoint on purpose, so a score cannot default to the centre.